Opposition in the discourse of argument
Date
1989
Authors
Shahin, Kimary N.
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
This thesis examines the discourse of argument in terms of 'opposition' as a 'generic feature ' . The presence of 'opposition' in argument is explored in order to see how it makes argument speech activity a coherent and distinctive event. 'Opposition' is found to operate on three discourse levels in argument. These are the Interactional , Topic and Sentence levels. 'Opposition' is located in talk wherever the Formulation/Decision (F/D) speech act pair occurs on these three levels, and where the Decision of the act pair is a disconfirmation (D-). A F/D- pair thus represents disagreement in discourse. Argument is defined as 'disagreement to disagreement'. On the basis of this definition , argument is located in talk wherever a F/D-/D- speech act sequence occurs on the three levels of discourse. An analysis of argument discourse data reveals the exact nature of the F/D-/D- sequence on each of the Interactional, Topic and Sentence Levels of discourse. These three sequences together present the full F/0-/D- sequence of argument. A method of analysis is developed by which this full sequence may be tracked and explained. Explaining t his sequence in valves determining the relationships between all acts in the sequence. Once these relationships are determined, the process of an argument is explained.
Based on the findings of the data analysis, certain observations on argument are made. These concern, among other issues, the use of illocutionary force (found in indirect speech) and of Rhetorical argument in argumentative discourse. In addition, the analysis reveals that the substantive basis of arguments which are 'had' is argument which is 'made' (the explicit or implicit claims or reasons produced by speakers). It is concluded that the coherence and distinctiveness of argument discourse is due in large part to the presence of the feature 'opposition'. It is tentatively claimed that argument without the feature 'opposition' will not occur. Thus, opposition may well be the essence of argument.