The effect of pre‑event instructions on eyewitness identification

Date

2023

Authors

Baldassari, Mario J.
Moore, Kara N.
Hyman, Ira E. Jr
Hope, Lorraine
Mah, Eric Y.
Lindsay, Stephen D.
Mansour, Jamal
Saraiva, Renan
Horry, Ruth
Rath, Hannah

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications

Abstract

Research on eyewitness identification often involves exposing participants to a simulated crime and later testing memory using a lineup. We conducted a systematic review showing that pre-event instructions, instructions given before event exposure, are rarely reported and those that are reported vary in the extent to which they warn participants about the nature of the event or tasks. At odds with the experience of actual witnesses, some studies use pre-event instructions explicitly warning participants of the upcoming crime and lineup task. Both the basic and applied literature provide reason to believe that pre-event instructions may affect eyewitness identification performance. In the current experiment, we tested the impact of pre-event instructions on lineup identification decisions and confidence. Participants received non-specific pre-event instructions (i.e., “watch this video”) or eyewitness pre-event instructions (i.e., “watch this crime video, you’ll complete a lineup later”) and completed a culprit-absent or -present lineup. We found no support for the hypothesis that participants who receive eyewitness pre-event instructions have higher discriminability than participants who receive non-specific pre-event instructions. Additionally, confidence-accuracy calibration was not significantly different between conditions. However, participants in the eyewitness condition were more likely to see the event as a crime and to make an identification than participants in the non-specific condition. Implications for conducting and interpreting eyewitness identification research and the basic research on instructions and attention are discussed.

Description

Thanks to Sydney Long, Jordyn Pope, Emily Walden, Alonna Rios, Audrie Cabrera, and Nikai Hinojosa for their work on coding all of those eyewitness identification papers! Thanks to Annelise Vredeveldt and Hayley Cullen for their contributions to the initial conversation that inspired this work. Thank you to Melissa Colloff, Ryan Fitzgerald, and Andrew Smith for their analytical advice and resources.

Keywords

Eyewitness identification, Lineup, Study instructions, Eyewitness memory

Citation

Baldassari, M. J., Moore, K. N., Hyman, I. E., Hope, L., Mah, E. Y., Lindsay, D. S., ... Wiechert, S. (2023). The effect of pre-event instructions on eyewitness identification. Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications, 8(16), https://doi.org/10.1186/s41235-023-00471-4